Denver Science Fiction & Fantasy Book Club |
Slan (1940, 1945, 1951, 1968) 2007 Tor trade paperback cover art from Astounding Science Fiction October 1940 cover art by Hubert Rogers 255 pages Dell 1953 1st paperback edition (right) |
1946 Arkham House 1st edition hardcover cover art by Robert E. Hubbell |
1960 UK Panther paperback |
1961 Ballantine paperback Cover by Richard Powers |
Dan | - | Amy | 6 |
10 Wow! Don't miss it 8-9 Highly recommended 7 Recommended 5-6 Mild recommendation 3-4 Take your chances 1-2 Below average; skip it 0 Get out the flamethrower! U Unfinishable or unreadable - Skipped or no rating given |
|
Cheri | - | Barb | - | ||
Aaron | 6 | Cynthia | - | ||
Jackie | 5.5 | Ron | 5 | ||
Jennifer | 5.5 |
Aaron's Commentary
A. E. van Vogt - Slan
To my mind, this novel does not compare favorably with van Vogt's best work, such as The Voyage of the Space Beagle and The Weapon Shops of Isher, and is remembered fondly mostly because it touched a nerve with Golden Age fans - Fans are slans! As always, van Vogt is entertaining and moves things along briskly, but the plot ranges between silly and nonsensical, and van Vogt fails to take the superman scenario anywhere interesting. Several of his contemporaries handled the concept much more adroitly, for example More Than Human by Theodore Sturgeon and Mutant by Henry Kuttner. What do you think? Your comments are welcome. Please send them to vanaaron@excite.com |