Denver Science Fiction & Fantasy Book Club |
All the Windwracked Stars (2008) Tor hardcover (left) Tor paperback 368 pages (right) cover art by Jean-Sébastien Rossbach |
Dan | 5 | Amy | 5 |
10 Wow! Don't miss it 8-9 Highly recommended 7 Recommended 5-6 Mild recommendation 3-4 Take your chances 1-2 Below average; skip it 0 Get out the flamethrower! U Unfinishable or unreadable - Skipped or no rating given |
|
Cheri | 3 | Barb | - | ||
Aaron | 3 | Cynthia | - | ||
Jackie | - | Ron | 4 | ||
Bob | 4 | Molly | 5 |
Aaron's Commentary
Elizabeth Bear - All the Windwracked Stars
This novel is a bit of a mess, far below the standard of other Elizabeth Bear works I've read. I like the concept of combining Norse mythology with a far future SFnal setting, but Bear fails to pull either off. She didn't give me any sense of the essence of Norse mythology, and her future world is a vague blur, with no effective explanation of how this society works or who lives there -- it all feels like a movie set of unconvincing facades painted over with a random mishmash of fantasy and SF elements, which never combine in any interesting way. Worst of all, the characters are cut from the same cardboard. I had no sense of what was motivating any of them or why I should care what happened to them. Still, I won't give up on Elizabeth Bear, because I know she can do a great deal better. What do you think? Your comments are welcome. Please send them to vanaaron@excite.com |